Kai Kalama, “What Becomes of the Broken Hearted”: 17
The vocal was pretty good, but I thought he just came off really old. And I kept waiting for that one big note to knock it out of the park and it never came. Plus, the backup singers didn’t do him any favors. Notice too that the show didn’t replay his story, but only barely mentioned his mother. That’s going to hurt him if people don’t remember.