Paige Miles, “Against All Odds”: 8
GROAN! This is one of those songs that should be banned from the Idol stage, so I had to give her a 0 in Song Choice. Honestly, the second verse and last chorus wasn’t all that bad, so why didn’t she go there sooner? I think Miley made her first mentoring mistake of the night by telling Paige that her soft voice was so powerful. A good mentor would have told her to go to the power notes sooner.