Siobhan Magnus, “When You Believe” 14
I love that song, but that arrangement was TERRIBLE! When she hit the ad-libs in that final verse, the backup singers should have been singing the chorus behind her. And I know I don’t rate appearance anymore, but what was that outfit? What was in her hair? And butterflies on her shoulder? What?
But clearly the show wants her around. Why else would Ryan have let her babble for two minutes about nothing when there is only 15 minutes with two singers and a recap to go? And if that song meant so much to her, why didn’t she show us that in her performance?