Okay, so let’s break this down. Who’s going to make up the bottom three? I think it’s definitely got to be three of the girls, so I’m going with Carly, Brooke and Kristy Lee.
And who’s going home? In this crazy, unpredictable season, it’s really hard to tell. But if it’s based on performances, I think it has to be Carly. It was just completely underwhelming. As Simon said, she’s just completely overthinking and it’s coming through in her performances.
So what do you think? Who’s going home tonight?
And more importantly, how hard did David Cook rock tonight? He may have just convinced me to buy Idol tour tickets…